Proverbs 27:17: “As iron sharpens iron, so one person sharpens another.”
I keep coming back to that line. Not as a decoration. As a way to read what actually happened when this country was arguing over the Constitution.
Madison split the power. The Anti-Federalists kept it close to the people. They sharpened each other. And the Bill of Rights — the part that is still useful to us today — came out of that fight.
So the question I want to test is simple:
Madison split the power, the Anti-Federalists kept it close to the people, so who holds the pens today?
The question, in my own words
I said it this way, and I want it on the record in my own wording, not cleaned up:
“that’s divide and conquer. Now the power is not in few hands but many many gatekeepers’ hands.”
“wow that’s the Federalist papers argument.”
“As for Madison’s argument many gatekeepers keep any one group from taking over…. and look at what many gatekeepers are keeping Trump from taking over… and it’s the anti-federalists actually gave us the bill of rights that are useful to today.”
Those are questions to test. They are not a verdict on Madison, on the Anti-Federalists, on Donald Trump, or on any board or court. Follow the pens. Read the originals. Willingness to relook at everything for the greater mission.
Iron sharpens iron
“How power gets divided, and how we put it back together,” we went back to the drawing table. The Articles of Confederation had stuck the pen: all thirteen states had to agree to a change, so one state could block twelve. The new plan split the pen three ways. Congress writes. The President carries out. The courts judge.
Federalist 51 put the idea in one sentence: “Ambition must be made to counteract ambition.”
That same paper also says, before the auxiliary precautions, “A dependence on the people is, no doubt, the primary control on the government; but experience has taught mankind the necessity of auxiliary precautions.”
That is We The People first, and the checks second.
What I had not yet put next to that lesson is the sharpening. Madison did not write the Bill of Rights in a quiet room by himself. The Anti-Federalists pressed him, and he pressed back, and a bill of rights was added. Iron sharpens iron.
Madison’s reading
In Federalist 10 — Teaching American History in November, 1787; — Madison argued that a large republic could break up the power of any one faction:
“Extend the sphere, and you take in a greater variety of parties and interests; you make it less probable that a majority of the whole will have a common motive to invade the rights of other citizens.”
That is the Federalist Papers argument I heard in the phrase “many gatekeepers keep any one group from taking over.” It is a fair reading of what he wrote. It is not the same thing as saying Madison designed today’s unelected boards, or that every modern gatekeeper is doing what he described. That leap stays a question.
On a bill of rights, his own words are more mixed than a slogan. On October 17, 1788, he wrote to Thomas Jefferson (The Founders’ Constitution, University of Chicago Press, Volume 1, Chapter 14, Document 47, Papers 11:297–300):
“My own opinion has always been in favor of a bill of rights; provided it be so framed as not to imply powers not meant to be included in the enumeration. At the same time I have never thought the omission a material defect, nor been anxious to supply it even by subsequent amendment, for any other reason than that it is anxiously desired by others.”
He favored it, and he also thought the omission was not a material defect. In the same letter he warned:
“Repeated violations of these parchment barriers have been committed by overbearing majorities in every State.”
“Parchment barriers” is his phrase, in that letter, for bills of rights that get broken when a majority is determined to break them. That is worth sitting with. A right on paper is not the same thing as a right that holds.
What I can document from the National Archives Bill of Rights transcript is this: “Ten of the proposed 12 amendments were ratified by three-fourths of the state legislatures on December 15, 1791.” Those ratified articles are the first ten amendments, the Bill of Rights.
The Tenth Amendment, in the Archives transcript of the enrolled original, says:
“The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people.”
That is the Anti-Federalist pressure, written into the parchment.
The Anti-Federalist reading
They were not a footnote. They were the other piece of iron.
Brutus 1, dated October 18, 1787 by Teaching American History, asked whether a country “so large and so numerous as they will soon become” could elect a representation “that will speak their sentiments, without their becoming so numerous as to be incapable of transacting public business? It certainly is not.” In a republic the size of this continent, Brutus wrote, “the people in general would be acquainted with very few of their rulers.”
Keep the power close enough that people actually know who holds it. That is the reading I mean when I say the Anti-Federalists kept it close to the people.
Teaching American History notes that Brutus is “generally assumed to have been Robert Yates, a New York delegate to the Constitutional Convention.”
Brutus 11, dated January 31, 1788 by Teaching American History, went after the courts:
“The opinions of the supreme court, whatever they may be, will have the force of law; because there is no power provided in the constitution, that can correct their errors, or controul their adjudications. From this court there is no appeal.”
(“Controul” is the spelling in the Teaching American History text.)
They wanted a bill of rights, and they wanted rulers the people could know and displace. Madison wanted a large sphere and ambition checking ambition, and he came around to adding the amendments other people were anxious to have. The sharpening produced something neither side would have written alone.
Who holds the pens today?
Here is the bridge from 1788 to California in 2026.
The earlier California Freemasons map asked whether builder power shifted sideways. The documented record in that map is that today’s building-code pens sit with groups such as the International Code Council (ICC), IAPMO, the California Building Standards Commission (CBSC), the California Department of Housing and Community Development, and local boards — not with a fraternity lodge writing the code. A membership or a historical overlap is a documented connection, not proof of intent. Secret control remains ⚠ unproven. And James Madison himself should not be folded into that story as a Mason. On January 24, 1832, he wrote to Stephen Bates (James Madison’s Montpelier, citing Library of Congress MRD-S 37437): “I never was a mason, and no one perhaps could be more a stranger to the principles, rites and fruits of the institution.”
So follow the pens that actually write the rules for what we may build.
The California Building Standards Commission Commissioners page says: “The members of the California Building Standards Commission (CBSC) are appointed by the Governor of California and confirmed by the State Senate. The cabinet secretary of the Government Operations Agency, or the secretary’s representative, serves as the Commission Chair.” You do not vote for those commissioners directly. You can vote for the Governor and for your State Senator. That is a real check, and it is also one step removed.
The CBSC Meetings page says there are “Opportunities for public comments before or during meetings marked with *.” On that calendar, the December 17, 2026 Commission Meeting is marked with a star and is also marked Cancelled. The next Commission Meeting marked with a star is January 21, 2027.
The International Code Council, on its Code Development Process page says it “develops construction and public safety codes through a governmental consensus process,” and that “Final decisions are made in an open hearing by public safety officials.” The same page says “One-third of the committee’s members must be public safety officials.” ⚠ The lines I opened do not say that only governmental members vote, so I am not saying that. You do not vote for the ICC. You can follow their process, if you can find the door.
Our wildfire scorecard asked a hard question that still stands: when there are many gatekeepers, who tracks whether homes actually survive? Year built on a parcel file is not the same thing as the code edition that applied to the house. I am not re-trying that count here. I am pointing at the same pattern.
Is this Madison’s “auxiliary precautions” working as designed? Or is it divide and conquer — “the power is not in few hands but many many gatekeepers hands” — with the people’s “primary control” too far away? I am leaving that as a question to test. Some key open doors, some key jail door lock. Who holds the pen?
“Keeping Trump from taking over” — two readings, no verdict
I also asked us to “look at what many gatekeepers are keeping Trump from taking over.” I am not going to turn that into a verdict on him, or on the people checking him. Fairness means two good-faith readings, both still questions:
- Institutions are checking a real abuse of executive power.
- Institutions are protecting their own pens.
The record can support a serious look at either reading. Motives are not something I can put down as fact.
One dated example — and only an example of a fight over the scope of a judicial remedy, not a ruling on the underlying policy — is Trump v. CASA, Inc., U.S. Supreme Court, No. 24A884, argued May 15, 2025, decided June 27, 2025. The Court held: “Universal injunctions likely exceed the equitable authority that Congress has given to federal courts.” It granted a partial stay “only to the extent that the injunctions are broader than necessary to provide complete relief to each plaintiff with standing to sue.” And it said, in so many words, that the applications “do not raise—and thus the Court does not address—the question whether the Executive Order violates the Citizenship Clause or Nationality Act.”
Read that carefully. The Court limited a kind of court order. It did not decide the citizenship question. Anyone who tells you the case “settled” that question is ahead of the page.
Brutus already worried, in 1788, that from the Supreme Court “there is no appeal.” Today’s argument over nationwide, or “universal,” injunctions is a later chapter of a very old question: who holds the judicial pen, and how far it reaches. That is a question. It is not a motive I am assigning to any justice or any president.
Then vs now: who holds the pen, who can vote them out
| Then / now | Who holds the pen | Who can vote them out, or check them |
|---|---|---|
| 1787–1791 Congress and the amendments | Elected House and Senate; the states ratified | Voters can change Congress; states said yes or no to ratification |
| Federal courts then and now | Appointed; life tenure during good behavior | Senate confirmation; impeachment. Brutus already asked what happens when “there is no appeal” |
| California Building Standards Commission, November 2026 | Members “appointed by the Governor of California and confirmed by the State Senate”; the Government Operations Agency secretary chairs (Commissioners page) | You do not vote for the commissioners directly. The Governor and the Senate are elected. Public comments are allowed before or during meetings marked with a star |
| ICC model codes, 2026 | ICC describes a “governmental consensus process” and says “Final decisions are made in an open hearing by public safety officials” (ICC Code Development Process page, opened this pass) | You do not vote for the International Code Council. |
| Your city or county building official, or board of appeals | Often appointed. The exact rule is local — that is the homework | Look it up this week. If you can vote them out, write that down. If you cannot, write down who appoints them |
In the fog of war, don’t take my word for it. Who holds the pen? Read it yourself.
One tool, one action
The tool and the action are the same as in the Wednesday Telegram lesson. One of each.
Tool: https://t.me/criticalthinkingisnotdead — bring your two facts back there.
ONE action, this week, from your phone: Open the California Building Standards Commission meetings page: https://www.dgs.ca.gov/BSC/Meetings. The December 17, 2026 Commission Meeting is marked cancelled. The next Commission Meeting starred for public comments is January 21, 2027 — put that date on your calendar. Then open the Commissioners page: https://www.dgs.ca.gov/BSC/About/Commissioners and write down who appoints them. Look up who appoints your city or county building official or board of appeals. Bring both facts back to the Telegram channel.
Wake up. Think critically. Show up.
Sources
- Proverbs 27:17, King James Version, labeled as scripture: “Iron sharpeneth iron; so a man sharpeneth the countenance of his friend.”
- Federalist No. 10. Teaching American History, November 22, 1787, https://teachingamericanhistory.org/document/federalist-10/. Avalon Project, “From the New York Packet. Friday, November 23, 1787,” https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/fed10.asp (both HTTP 200). “Extend the sphere…” is from the Avalon text. Both dates are disclosed.
- Federalist No. 51. Founders Online https://founders.archives.gov/documents/Madison/01-10-02-0279 dated it February 6, 1788 (opened October 31, 2026, for the prior Wednesday lesson). This pass, founders.archives.gov returned HTTP 202. Avalon https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/fed51.asp (HTTP 200) prints “From the New York Packet. Friday, February 8, 1788.” The “Ambition…” and “dependence on the people…” quotes were re-read from Avalon today and match the October 31 reading. Both dates are disclosed. Last week’s Telegram post used February 6 only.
- Madison to Jefferson, 17 Oct. 1788. The Founders’ Constitution, University of Chicago Press, Vol. 1, Ch. 14, Doc. 47, Papers 11:297–300, https://press-pubs.uchicago.edu/founders/documents/v1ch14s47.html (HTTP 200). Founders Online for this letter was HTTP 202 empty this pass.
- Brutus 1 (October 18, 1787) and Brutus 11 (January 31, 1788). Teaching American History, https://teachingamericanhistory.org/document/brutus-i/ and https://teachingamericanhistory.org/document/brutus-xi/ (HTTP 200). Yates attribution is TAH’s, and is labeled as such.
- Bill of Rights / Tenth Amendment / December 15, 1791. National Archives transcript, https://www.archives.gov/founding-docs/bill-of-rights-transcript (HTTP 200).
- ⚠ June 8, 1789 speech: not successfully opened this pass (Founders 202; multiple TAH, House, Senate, Archives, NPS, and Miller Center URLs 404 or error pages; LOC “Today in History – June 8” did not mention it). Not quoted; date not treated as confirmed from a page opened today.
- Trump v. CASA, Inc., No. 24A884, argued May 15, 2025, decided June 27, 2025. Supreme Court slip opinion / syllabus, opened this pass. Used only as a dated example of a remedies question, with the Court’s own limit that it did not decide the Executive Order / Citizenship Clause question.
- CBSC Commissioners: https://www.dgs.ca.gov/BSC/About/Commissioners (HTTP 200). Appointment and chair wording quoted from that page.
- CBSC Meetings: https://www.dgs.ca.gov/BSC/Meetings (HTTP 200). Public-comment star rule; December 17, 2026 Commission Meeting cancelled; next starred Commission Meeting January 21, 2027.
- ICC Code Development Process: https://www.iccsafe.org/products-and-services/i-codes/code-development/ (HTTP 200). “Governmental consensus process” and “Final decisions are made in an open hearing by public safety officials.” The page’s “highest level of safety in the world” line is not repeated as our claim. “Only governmental members vote” is not claimed.
- Madison and Masonry. James Madison’s Montpelier, essay on Madison and Freemasonry, citing Madison to Stephen Bates, January 24, 1832, Library of Congress MRD-S 37437. The earlier “⚠ not on record” caution is strengthened, not reversed: Madison said he was not a Mason.
- Washington lodge dates, for the chat record. Mount Vernon Digital Encyclopedia, “Freemasonry,” https://www.mountvernon.org/library/digitalhistory/digital-encyclopedia/article/freemasonry (HTTP 200): Entered Apprentice at the Lodge at Fredericksburg, Virginia, November 4, 1752; Fellowcraft March 3, 1753; Master Mason August 4, 1753; also recorded September 1, 1753, and January 4, 1755. Honorary member of Alexandria Lodge No. 39 in 1784; charter master about four years later when the lodge transferred from the Grand Lodge of Pennsylvania to the Grand Lodge of Virginia; after his death the lodge was renamed Alexandria-Washington Lodge No. 22. “Alexandria No. 22 Master” is slightly loose.
- Franklin as Grand Master of Pennsylvania, 1734: ⚠ not confirmed from a page opened this pass. Montpelier states that Washington and Franklin were Masons. The 1734 office stays unverified here.
- Site check. takigndownthegiants.com did not load. https://takingdownthegiants.com/ returned HTTP 200. Series notes from blog-to-action.md (212 posts read October 30, 2026; Essay #44 published July 9, 2026).
- Tool and action are the same single tool and single action as the Telegram lesson. The Scissors & Keys tools-page URL was not used, because an earlier November 10 post noted that URL should not go up until the zip is uploaded and the page loads.